Is There a Feminist Text in Jane Eyre?--A Reappraisal

• 作者: Yinghuei Chen
• 来源期刊: 文学与艺术研究:英文版
• 学科: 文学
• 关键词: women WRITING FEMINIST a FEMINIST TEXT proto-feminism PRAGMATISM realist
• 年，卷（期）: wxyysyjywb_2019,（1）
• 页码范围: 25-34
• 页数: 10页
• 分类号: H31

摘要

After the publication of Virginia Woolf’s A Room of One’s Own(1929),which to many critics marked the beginning of a sustained thinking about women writing and feminist literary theory,it has become a commonplace to read Jane Eyre as a feminist text.Evidences in the novel,though not abundant,can be found to support such a reading.But Jane Eyre is not an enumeration of the rights of women,neither is it a manifesto or a catalogue of wrongs done unto women by society.Wherever the text refers to women having similar ambitions to men,as shown in a passage often quoted in Chapter XII of the book,we must bear in mind that Jane,an orphan placed in an unloving home,a brutal school and an unsympathetic employment environment,must make her way in life as best she can.She has no time for feminist sentiment,her survival allows for nothing outside of her own labor.To suggest that Jane is expressing herself as a feminist by taking up employment is ludicrous;she is merely surviving as countless male characters likewise do.Jane’s pragmatism is given further heft by her reaction to Bertha’s death.Bertha dead is a problem solved,a barrier removed.If she has to tweak the narrative to allow for this then she will,the ex-servant’s reiteration of Bertha’s death is pregnant with self justification,not his but Jane’s.Indeed Jane’s good sense,adaptability and,above all,awareness of her personal circumstances are given as causes for her pragmatic decision-making.This may seem a brutal scheme of values but it is all she has to work with.Rather than searching for Bront?’s true voice in the text and,thereby,attempting to graft onto it a proto-feminism,we should instead recognize Jane’s true voice coming through that of the ex-servant.Far from being feminist,a thought Jane cannot indulge,she is the supreme realist,willing,in the final analysis to disregard even murder in the pursuit of her own safety and repose.Jane is an expression of Bront?in that both are women of dubious background,seeking success in a world so far out o